January 21st — 5 Potential Pocono STRs
Hey crew!
Welcome to Week 2 of The STR Shortlist. We’re kicking things off with a curated selection of STR properties and insights from around the Poconos to help you start strong and stay ahead.
Let’s dive in.
📍 Connect with a Local STR Pro
Pick #1 - Pine Haven Getaway
🪵 353 Scotch Pine Drive, Pocono Summit, PA

Listed by Roman Lytvyn- Bairo Real Estate- Bartonsville
Discover a beautifully proportioned single-family home in Pocono Summit, offering 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 2,224 sq ft of living space in an STR-friendly community. This inviting residence features expansive living areas, a cozy fireplace, and a flexible layout perfect for everyday living, entertaining, or rental potential. Set on a 0.28-acre lot, it combines tranquil suburban living with convenient access to local amenities and excellent schools, making it an ideal place to call home.
Key Features: Curb appeal, massive deck, fairly priced!
Pick #2 - Mink Manor
💡 2115 Mink Lane, Long Pond, PA

Listed by C.J. Clover- The Collective Real Estate Agency
Welcome to 2115 Mink Ln., a 2001-built home with approximately 3,100 sq. ft. of living space in the Poconos, blending modern upgrades with rustic charm. This property features a 1,300 sq. ft. deck with a custom pergola, a sauna, and a spa, along with stunning interior finishes and Wi-Fi-controlled thermostats for energy efficiency. With recent upgrades, including a new septic system approved for 5-bedroom rentals, the home generated $120K in bookings in 2024, making it a highly profitable short-term rental investment on a rare double lot.
Key Features: Proven track record, square footage, staple amenities!
Pick #3 - Lakeside Bliss
⛰ 86 Longfellow Circle, Albrightsville, PA

Listed by Mary Enck- Mary Enck Realty Inc
Experience year-round lakefront living in this beautifully appointed 3-bedroom home with an additional office and stunning water views, located in the desirable Towamensing Trails community. The property features modern updates, including a kitchen with cherry wood cabinets, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances, along with an expansive primary suite that has a private bath, walk-in closet, and double sliding doors to the deck. Enjoy outdoor amenities such as a private dock and beach area for swimming, kayaking, and fishing, making this a perfect retreat for full-time living, vacationing, or investment.
Key Features: LAKEFRONT, private dock, desired HOA!
Pick #4 - The Crabapple Mansion
😲 282 Crabapple Lane, East Stroudsburg, PA

Listed by Carol C Dorey- Carol C Dorey Inc
This historic circa 1863 home, set on 50 pristine acres and just under two hours from New York City, offers a unique investment opportunity for short-term rental. Recently renovated, it features heart pine floors, a chef's kitchen with an Italian pizza oven, a romantic primary suite, and three additional bedrooms with ensuite baths, all designed for guest comfort. Outdoor amenities include a stunning c.1880s dining room, an in-ground pool, a spring-fed pond, and trails, while being conveniently located within five minutes of grocery shopping and restaurants.
Key Features: Extreme character, large barn onsite, endless opportunity, hiking trails!
Pick #5 - 6 Stars at Lake Harmony
🐟 70 Pineknoll Drive, Lake Harmony, PA

Listed by Derek Eisenberg- Continental R.E. Group, Inc
This turnkey 6-bedroom, 2-bath short-term rental boasts a strong income history and future bookings, making it ideal for investors seeking immediate cash flow. Recently updated, it features a brand-new kitchen with white shaker cabinets, quartz counters, and an open living/dining layout, with three bedrooms and a renovated bath on the upper level, and three additional bedrooms and a second bath on the lower level. Outdoor amenities include a two-tier deck, hot tub, tiki bar, firepit, and parking for six, all located in The Estates with access to lake and beach amenities.
Key Features: Bedroom Count, strong rental history, modern interior!
📍Ready to meet a Pocono Short Term Rental Pro?
Meet a local REALTOR 👨💼
Schedule a 30 minute optimization call ⚙️
Connect with a STR expert in The Pocono Mountains 🪵
🚨 IMPORTANT Disclosure: The STR Shortlist is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or real estate advice. All properties and insights shared involve risk, and readers are solely responsible for conducting their own due diligence, analysis, and decision-making before pursuing any investment.
Until next week,
The STR Shortlist
