January 11th — 5 Potential Pocono STRs
Hey crew!
Welcome to Week 1 of The STR Shortlist. We’re kicking things off with a curated selection of STR properties and insights from around the Poconos to help you start strong and stay ahead.
Let’s dive in.
📍 Connect with a Local STR Pro
Pick #1 - The Pineknoll Palace
🪵 136 Pineknoll Dr, Lake Harmony, PA
Listed by Vincent Capria - DiMaria Realty LLC
Warm, inviting, and built for unforgettable stays, this 6BR / 3BA four-season chalet is a standout retreat in Lake Harmony Estates. From the hot tub and wrap-around deck to the indoor and outdoor fireplaces, every element is designed to deliver comfort and a true “wow” factor.
Key Features: Curb appeal, true “Pocono” style, & Location!
Pick #2 - 6 Bedroom Stunner
💡 401 Clearview Dr, Long Pond, PA
Listed by Alyssa Haines - RE/MAX Crossroads
6-bedroom, 2-bath raised chalet in the amenity-rich Emerald Lakes community, offering strong flexibility for a vacation home, STR investment, or full-time residence. The home features vaulted ceilings with exposed beams, an open-concept living area, an expansive wraparound deck, and a lower level with additional bedrooms, recreation space, and a second full bath with laundry.
Key Features: Bedroom Count, Fixer-Upper Opportunities, & Curb Appeal!
Pick #3 - Lake Harmony Luxe
⛰ 217 S Lake Dr, Lake Harmony, PA
Listed By Nosheen Hayat - Smart Way America Realty
Newly built 9-bedroom, 6.5-bath luxury home in Lake Harmony with beautiful water views and a proven active short-term rental. The property features a theatre room, expansive great room, and covered decks designed for year-round enjoyment. Sold turn-key with future bookings in place, making it a seamless investment opportunity.
Key Features: A+ Curb Appeal, Lake View, & Amenities!
Pick #4 - Milford Money Maker
😲 5951 Milford Rd, East Stroudsburg, PA
Listed By Alexander Schwartz - RE/MAX Preferred
Turn-key Stone Cabin Resort on 5+ acres in the Poconos, averaging $190K/year in STR income. This 4BR, 2.5BA home with two kitchens was fully renovated in 2022 and is sold furnished with a 4.81-star Superhost account. Standout amenities include a detached indoor heated pool with 120” projector, no HOA, multi-zoning, and room to expand near top Pocono attractions.
Key Features: Indoor Pool, Extreme Revenue, & No HOA!
Pick #5 - The Lakefront Legend
🐟 7814 Lake Shore Dr, Pocono Lake, PA
Listed By Christopher C. George - Keller Williams Northampton
Beautifully updated 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath lakefront home in the Poconos with expansive water views and open-concept living. Features include a 2-story foyer, modern kitchen, spacious living areas, and a primary suite with sitting room and balcony. Three levels of living offer guest rooms, multiple full baths, and seamless flow to a large deck and direct lake access for kayaking, fishing, and recreation. Ideal as a serene getaway, full-time residence, or high-demand short-term rental.
Key Features: Lakefront, Rooftop Deck, & Unique Design!
📍Ready to meet a Pocono Short Term Rental Pro?
Meet a local REALTOR 👨💼
Schedule a 30 minute optimization call ⚙️
Connect with a STR expert in The Pocono Mountains 🪵
🚨 IMPORTANT Disclosure: The STR Shortlist is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or real estate advice. All properties and insights shared involve risk, and readers are solely responsible for conducting their own due diligence, analysis, and decision-making before pursuing any investment.
Until next week,
The STR Shortlist