February 3rd — 5 Potential Pocono STRs
Hey crew!
Welcome to Week 4.1 of The STR Shortlist. We’re kicking things off with a curated selection of STR properties and insights from around the Poconos to help you start strong and stay ahead.
Let’s dive in.
📍 Connect with a Local STR Pro
Pick #1 - The Forester
🪵 2449 Forest Dr E, Pocono Lake, PA
Listed by Christine Lacomis - Lewith & Freeman, Kingston
A modern retreat immersed in nature, this home blends comfort, style, and privacy. The chef’s kitchen showcases GE Café appliances and an oversized island perfect for everyday living and entertaining, complemented by hickory floors throughout the open layout. An architect-designed studio office, newer roof, and whole-house generator provide both functionality and peace of mind. Welcome home to Wagner Forest Park.
Key Features: Pocono Style, Amenity Space, & Modern Design!
Pick #2 - The Lakefront Lookout
🛶 1441 Waterfront Dr, Tobyhanna, PA
Listed by Ewa Zaba - Smart Way America Realty
Stunning 5-bed, 3-bath lakefront home operating as a successful STR, featuring a chef’s kitchen with granite countertops, open dining with water views, and a private dock for boating and fishing. Minutes to all major Pocono attractions.
Key Features: LAKEFRONT, Modern Exterior, & A+ Design
Pick #3 - Sequoia’s Pitch
🪵 3620 Sequoia Dr, East Stroudsburg, PA
Listed by Jess Keller - Keller Williams Real Estate
Modern alpine-style chalet on a private .76-acre lot in the heart of the Pocono Mountains, close to year-round attractions. This sun-filled home features cathedral ceilings, a cozy living room with brick wood stove, and a remodeled kitchen with new stainless steel appliances. The main level includes a primary suite with Jacuzzi tub, plus a flexible loft ideal for a third bedroom or office. Enjoy multiple decks and an oversized detached garage!
Key Features: A-Frame style, Cozy Feel, & Curb Appeal!
Pick #4 - The Stillwater Stunner
😲 294 Stillwater Dr, Pocono Summit, PA
Listed by Michael Klein - eXp Realty, LLC
Turnkey, cash-flowing STR with a legal 6BR and a proven $750K in rental income over 5 years (4.98 rating, 129 reviews). Set on a rare double lot nearing an acre, just a short walk to the lake, with room to add amenities and boost returns.
Key Features: $200k+ Revenue, 4.98 Stars, & Lot Size!
Pick #5 - Buck’s Palace
🦌 3326 Buck Run, Tobyhanna, PA
Listed By Tina McGovern - Keller Williams Real Estate-Clarks Summit
Move-in ready 4-bedroom, 3-bath home in Pocono Farms Country Club featuring an open layout, abundant natural light, and a first-floor primary suite. Major updates include a new roof (Aug 2024), privacy fence (Sept 2024), and mini-split HVAC system (July 2025). Enjoy multiple outdoor spaces with a screened-in porch, rear deck, and welcoming front porch, all set back from the road for privacy and ample parking plus a 2-car garage. Scheduled showings begin after the Open House.
Key Features: Size, Ceiling Height, & Amenity Space!
📍Ready to meet a Pocono Short Term Rental Pro?
Meet a local REALTOR 👨💼
Schedule a 30 minute optimization call ⚙️
Connect with a STR expert in The Pocono Mountains 🪵
🚨 IMPORTANT Disclosure: The STR Shortlist is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or real estate advice. All properties and insights shared involve risk, and readers are solely responsible for conducting their own due diligence, analysis, and decision-making before pursuing any investment.
Until next week,
The STR Shortlist